Showing posts with label Prog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prog. Show all posts
Tuesday, April 28, 2020
#3808 Once and Future Band - Deleted Scenes
3/5 so so slick. Shamelessly pop prog, reviving the least cool era of the least cool good music around, whitewashed jazzy flourishes, jamband wanderings, and some admittedly pretty great organ runs, all in perfectly bite-sized units. Undeniably catchy, tough to listen to with a straight face
Monday, December 9, 2019
#3673 Flowers Must Die - Kompost
3/5 just 6 more months till I can quit this project. none of this made an impression on me, all its swirling and yowling and warbles and surges and rages just mix to grey, or maybe I've gone colorblind
Thursday, December 5, 2019
#3672 Anthony Phillips - The Geese and The Ghost
3/5 pleasant enough for the prog fan. But hemmed in, riding classical coattails without enough of a voice to carry things to the next level. A departure from the soon-expanding Genesis feels inevitable in retrospect
Thursday, November 21, 2019
#3659 FM - Black Noise
3.5/5 those synth lines are the equalizer here, cutting right through all the bombast like a laser sword, a throughline into the foliage. Mostly utterly goofy, just look at those scifi songtitles, but those synth hooks're so bright, so cleanly, boldly realized, they'll make you grin in spite of yourself
Wednesday, November 20, 2019
#3657 Strawbs - Hero and Heroine
4/5 been hitting the prog _pre_ty hard lately, and this taps into the mother vein of my love of Genesis and rides it into the night. Those bellowing mellotrons, those romantic, sweeping climaxes, those flagrantly Gabrielesque vocals, all woven with perfect flow.
Sweeping pacing, and two gorgeous moments perfectly placed, like a movie might be paced, at the end of the opening salvo and as we achieve sweet denouement.
In the best prog rock you don't even notice that something complex is happening; the means not the ends. As in film, that's the line between the understated masterpiece and the arty wank; the best straddle it. Semicolons for everyone!
Profoundly sensitive, deeply uncool, but really quite a nice little swoon
Sweeping pacing, and two gorgeous moments perfectly placed, like a movie might be paced, at the end of the opening salvo and as we achieve sweet denouement.
In the best prog rock you don't even notice that something complex is happening; the means not the ends. As in film, that's the line between the understated masterpiece and the arty wank; the best straddle it. Semicolons for everyone!
Profoundly sensitive, deeply uncool, but really quite a nice little swoon
Thursday, November 7, 2019
#3647 Premiata Forneria Marconi - Per Un Amico
4/5 part of the appeal of prog is the sheer ambition, that building of a rocket meant for the moon, and while so many crash and burn or recede into theater, sometimes a band really gets there. Here's a rare case where all that complexity and pomposity achieves something like transcendence, overwhelms your intellect and sweeps what left to another place
Tuesday, November 5, 2019
#3644 Happy the Man - Happy the Man
3.5/5 fun, but in that kind of studied classical sense of playfulness, a dalliance from the norms of form and don't you get it? not anything that's actual fun in any way that your body would understand. Fun like good whiskey, not like the cheap stuff -- enjoyable sure but not fun exactly at all
Monday, November 4, 2019
#3643 Crack the Sky - Crack the Sky
4.5/5 there were a handful of prog bands you could call playful, in a classical bullshit sense (see, say, Happy the Man) but this might the only prog album where you felt like the band was having any actual fucking _fun; was interested in you having some too, in an actual rock and roll sense. There's all those start-stops and strange Scary structures, but it's in the service of humor, headbobbing, maybe even dancing. Goddamn delightful, Thin Lizzy / Cheap Trick listenable, with all that arty archness just there to put a hitch in your hipmoves. Killer fucking album flow (Robots for Ronnie aside) too
#3642 Can - Future Days
4/5 as loose, organic, inevitable as krautrock can be. Unperformed, more likely discovered, buried in ash and rubble, a earthen lesson to '73, today, later. Brilliant, patient jams unspooling
#3641 Magma - Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh
3.5/5 ain't nothing like it, credit for that. A yelping, churning blood ritual, building to a fever pitch, keening vocals falling all over themselves as the master arrives
Thursday, October 31, 2019
#3639 Caravan - In the Land of Grey and Pink
3/5 this's what happens when the bass player is the singer - the basslines are so high in the mix, they pull focus and reduce the rest of the countless instruments to texture and its a damn shame. That balance works on the funkier, catchier tracks like the opener and title track -- which are fucking great! But man. That last epic should be catnip. But it unspools as meandering jazz noodling, the bass overwhelming the solos, an ugly, indulgent sidelong slog
Wednesday, October 30, 2019
#3637 Kansas - Leftoverture
2.5/5 oversmooth pop and big dumb hard rock tarted up with an affectation of prog's complexity and a legitimate portion of its pretentiousness. The worst of both worlds
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
#3629 Camel - Mirage
4/5 my kind of prog, knotted and swervy, but engaged with the human experience, interested in taking you on an adventure, aware of your limits, alternating tests and rests. With a damn fine eye for melody too. A good trip
#3628 Gentle Giant - Octopus
2.5/5 baroque, obtuse, purple nonsense, and I say that as someone who _likes _prog. Why just have a melody when you could hocket it hither and tither till it falls apart? Why pace your music in confirmation or thoughtful defiance of human expectation when you could scatter starts and stops as if mastered by some unknowable math equation? "Why not when you could" asked endlessly until unlistenable, then a little more
Wednesday, September 12, 2018
#3059 Marillion - Script for a Jeter's Tear
This really does sound almost plausibly like the album that Genesis would have made after Hackett left. Except they would have never so flagrantly revisited their own riffs, and even mopey creeper Phil Collins wouldn't have swerved this hard into lovelorn moaning. How does a band nearly-named after a Tolkien book drop all the mythology in favor of 7/4 torch songs? If this was a Genesis album, this would have been their second worst to date*, but still miles better than And Then There Were Three 3/5
* sorry From Genesis to Revelations
* sorry From Genesis to Revelations
Wednesday, September 5, 2018
#3047 Gong - Camembert Electrique
The perfect bridge between 60's psychadelia and 70's prog, with enough impossible flourishes in between to make it beyond description. A messy, unmissable, thrashing golden disaster 4.5/5
Friday, August 31, 2018
#3041 U.K. - U.K.
Rock demands you move forward, but this too-late post-Boston // Genesis // Yes pop-riffage is good fun, with a hint of chin-scratchery as a stale bonus. Buzzy synths find a comfortable home among all the classical guitar and poppity bass and grasping vocals.
Backhanded praise is the only kind left for those late to a style built on newness. England, man. Lines are tight. My head did bob. Democracy among the parts, born of their impressive lineage maybe, makes for a snaky, enchanting listen for those with leftover patience for enchantment 4/5
Backhanded praise is the only kind left for those late to a style built on newness. England, man. Lines are tight. My head did bob. Democracy among the parts, born of their impressive lineage maybe, makes for a snaky, enchanting listen for those with leftover patience for enchantment 4/5
Wednesday, August 22, 2018
#3029 Mike Oldfied - Hergest Ridge
If there was any debate about whether Tubular Bells was overrated this settles it - a vastly better album, with more highlights, better flow, and none of the clunky distractions. Tubular Bells is also fine and good - just not a masterpiece so much as arriving at a time and place hungry for a savior. Where Bells chopped sloppily between ideas, Ridge breathes, develops, blossoms, with the hypnosis of ambient achieved through melodies so clean you barely notice their passing.
And its still an indulgent wank. And it's crazy that this topped any country's charts (good trivia there). But better than most if it's what you're in the market for, overflowing with a sense of wonder for the world, riding contours, gasping open into space, a sunrise where you try to suck in the moment and hold it hardened in yourself for later, ideally forever 4.5/5
And its still an indulgent wank. And it's crazy that this topped any country's charts (good trivia there). But better than most if it's what you're in the market for, overflowing with a sense of wonder for the world, riding contours, gasping open into space, a sunrise where you try to suck in the moment and hold it hardened in yourself for later, ideally forever 4.5/5
Tuesday, August 21, 2018
#3027 Premiata Forneria Marconi - Storia Di Un Minuto
I knocked PFM as Genesis wannabes when I heard Photos of Ghosts, but their debut has its own magic. Still some galloping Nice-via-Knifeism, but its own raucous energy too, some real kneechopping synth beauty, and dozens of elegant surprises. This's a band possessed, pulled by unseen forces and pulling you along. Wildly strange and elegant and mysterious, complex without being showy. How prog outta be 4.5/5
#3024 Mike Oldfied - Tubular Bells
An experimental instrumental album full of strange sounds, remarkably cleanly-realized -- plus a few moments of truly beautiful, ethereal melody. The focus on the sub-song realizations in isolation, stitched together after the fact, is a double-edged sword. Each section feels free of convention, living outside of existing music. And the ones that work, do they work. Italian chef finger kiss.
But they don't flow into eachother especially well, and _woof some of them fall flat. The side-enders, especially, jesus. The naming of the instruments out loud as they come in is not a gimmick that's aged well, and the Sailor Hornpipe outro's a heinous spell-breaker. Classical-aping clunkers infiltrate most of the best stretches.
--
If you're interested in the history of rock at all, this is a real interesting data point. It _dominated the British charts for _years and sold 15 millions albums worldwide and man its a weird record. Assuredly one of the weirdest to make that kind of impact. It speaks to the post-60's hangover we were facing, maybe: all that hope for music and where did it get us?
It's a bit like how people today root for Tiger to best Nicklaus, James over Jordan.
We're all on team this-generation.
We need to have something that shows us the time we're living in is culturally valid -- that _we're culturally valid. And its hard to escape the idea that this album's success came from some variation of that desire, that lifting it up was some collective delusion that affirmed that we were living in the best time yet.
England in particular, still chasing the British-invasion-high of being the center of culture, seemed to _will this into being a _thing. Fast forward to Oasis. The hype cycle there's its own beast.
It's not that Tubular Bells isn't good, it has its moments. But the idea that two 20-plus minute formless sound-collages was must-have for the general music populace anywhere in the Western world, that it broke records reserved for Jackson and the Beatles, is deeply unusual in the history of modern music. A moment when art music was popular. Man that time seems far away.
--
Tubular Bells is super messy, wildly, uneven, and its legend is blown way out of proportion. But there's a real spark of originality there, and in the post-then-now-now, man you can how rare its particular gift was 4/5
But they don't flow into eachother especially well, and _woof some of them fall flat. The side-enders, especially, jesus. The naming of the instruments out loud as they come in is not a gimmick that's aged well, and the Sailor Hornpipe outro's a heinous spell-breaker. Classical-aping clunkers infiltrate most of the best stretches.
--
If you're interested in the history of rock at all, this is a real interesting data point. It _dominated the British charts for _years and sold 15 millions albums worldwide and man its a weird record. Assuredly one of the weirdest to make that kind of impact. It speaks to the post-60's hangover we were facing, maybe: all that hope for music and where did it get us?
It's a bit like how people today root for Tiger to best Nicklaus, James over Jordan.
We're all on team this-generation.
We need to have something that shows us the time we're living in is culturally valid -- that _we're culturally valid. And its hard to escape the idea that this album's success came from some variation of that desire, that lifting it up was some collective delusion that affirmed that we were living in the best time yet.
England in particular, still chasing the British-invasion-high of being the center of culture, seemed to _will this into being a _thing. Fast forward to Oasis. The hype cycle there's its own beast.
It's not that Tubular Bells isn't good, it has its moments. But the idea that two 20-plus minute formless sound-collages was must-have for the general music populace anywhere in the Western world, that it broke records reserved for Jackson and the Beatles, is deeply unusual in the history of modern music. A moment when art music was popular. Man that time seems far away.
--
Tubular Bells is super messy, wildly, uneven, and its legend is blown way out of proportion. But there's a real spark of originality there, and in the post-then-now-now, man you can how rare its particular gift was 4/5
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)